16 Games like Mafia on Xbox that you should try

Its point of contact with Mafia is shooting mechanics, dark, oppressive atmosphere and open world exploration. Both also lean on exploration and discovery, and a third-person camera. The distance is in setting and visuals — its own ground is horror setting and crafting mechanics.

It resembles Mafia most in how it is built: shooting mechanics, dark, oppressive atmosphere and open world exploration. The common ground extends to stealth mechanics and single-player focus. Where the two diverge is setting and visuals: post-apocalyptic world and a first-person view.

Genre puts it alongside Mafia, and so does punishing difficulty, melee combat and multiplayer gameplay. Where the two diverge is visuals and tone: a casual, approachable feel and offline play.

What brings it close to Mafia is strong narrative focus, open world exploration and stealth mechanics, and the two track each other on genre, game mode and tone. The common ground extends to exploration and discovery, and multiplayer gameplay. Where the two diverge is setting and visuals: post-apocalyptic world and a first-person view.

The genre is the same as Mafia’s, and with it dark, oppressive atmosphere, melee combat and single-player focus. Both also lean on a third-person camera. The distance is in setting and visuals — its own ground is a cyberpunk setting and an isometric view.

Held in common with Mafia: shooting mechanics, strong narrative focus and melee combat. Both also lean on historical setting and single-player focus. The distance is in visuals — its own ground is a first-person view.

The genre is the same as Mafia’s, and with it strong narrative focus, melee combat and single-player focus. The distance is in setting and visuals — its own ground is ranged combat and horror setting.

The common ground with Mafia is structural: shooting mechanics, strong narrative focus and open world exploration. The common ground extends to exploration and discovery, and multiplayer gameplay. Where the two diverge is setting and visuals: post-apocalyptic world and a first-person view.

The thread back to Mafia runs through shooting mechanics, dark, oppressive atmosphere and melee combat. Both also lean on historical setting and single-player focus. The distance is in visuals and setting — its own ground is horror setting and a first-person view.

What carries over from Mafia is shooting mechanics, strong narrative focus and open world exploration. The common ground extends to stealth mechanics and single-player focus. Where the two diverge is setting and visuals: a sci-fi setting and skill tree progression.

Same family as Mafia: punishing difficulty, melee combat and single-player focus. The distance is in setting and visuals — its own ground is ranged combat and a cartoon aesthetic.

Shelved next to Mafia for good reason: dark, oppressive atmosphere, melee combat and single-player focus. They part company on visuals and combat: this one brings pixel art.

On paper it is what Mafia is — dark, oppressive atmosphere, melee combat and single-player focus — though the resemblance is mostly at that level. Where the two diverge is visuals and combat: ranged combat and an isometric view.

On paper it is what Mafia is — dark, oppressive atmosphere, melee combat and single-player focus — though the resemblance is mostly at that level. Where the two diverge is setting and visuals: horror setting and co-op play.

Genre puts it alongside Mafia, and so does punishing difficulty, melee combat and single-player focus. The distance is in setting and visuals — its own ground is a cyberpunk setting and a first-person view.